Tuesday, March 9, 2021

“Holtermann” Mansion - Lavender Bay - NSW

Holtermann’s Mansion (“The Towers”) – Lavender Bay / North Sydney – NSW

Boom-era Italianate mansion with viewing tower · Completed 1874–75 for Bernhardt Otto Holtermann · Demolished / encased mid-1930s within Sydney Church of England Grammar School (Shore)

Gold paid for the tower; the tower paid for the panorama. Holtermann’s Italianate pile above Lavender Bay was less a quiet villa than a camera platform — Charles Bayliss’s wet-plate harbour views from twenty-seven metres up still define colonial Sydney for many scrapbook readers. Shore School swallowed the site; the 1930s brick encasement finished what time had started.

At a glance

  • Name: The Towers (North Sydney Council / contemporary press); live blog “Holterman Mansion”
  • Location: ridge above Lavender Bay, near Blue and William Streets, North Sydney (At Home in North Sydney)
  • Built: commenced wealth-phase move 1874; house completed 1875 (At Home); ADB: palatial house with tower completed 1874 on heights of St Leonards — keep 1874–75 range
  • Builder / owner: Bernhardt Otto Holtermann (1838–1885) — gold miner, MLA St Leonards, photography patron
  • Style: boom-era Italianate with dominant central tower (c.27 m vantage), verandahs, classical pilasters (At Home description)
  • Famous use: platform for Charles Bayliss / Holtermann large-format harbour panoramas (Philadelphia 1876 etc.)
  • After Holtermann: bought by Thomas Dibbs (of neighbouring Graythwaite); sold to Sydney Church of England Grammar School (Shore)
  • Fate: mid-1930s — house and tower encased in modern brickwork and essentially demolished (At Home); Shore campus occupies the ground
  • Spelling fixes: Holtermann (not Holterman); Lavender Bay (not Lavendar/Lavander)

Site & setting

North Sydney / St Leonards heights overlooking Lavender Bay and the harbour — Cammeraygal Country. Holtermann first occupied sprawling St Leonards Lodge at Crows Nest, then built The Towers on the ridge. Neighbouring Graythwaite (Dibbs) frames the later sale story. The tower’s purpose was photography as much as display: views north-east and north-west as well as the famous harbour sweep (At Home).

Timeline

  • 1838 – Bernhardt Otto Holtermann born Hamburg (ADB).
  • 1858–59 – Arrives Australia; meets Beyers; Hill End / Hawkins Hill years.
  • 19–20 Oct 1872 – Star of Hope / Holtermann specimen — world’s largest reef-gold specimen tradition (ADB: 630 lb / 286 kg). Soft: some popular pages round wealth to “1871”.
  • c.1871–74 – Leaves active prospecting; Sydney years; St Leonards Lodge then mansion project.
  • 1874–75 – The Towers built/completed; stained-glass window of Holtermann with the “nugget” (ADB).
  • 1875 – Bayliss panoramas from the unfinished/finished tower; claimed among largest wet-plate photographs.
  • 1876 / 1878 – Exhibition medals Philadelphia / Paris (ADB).
  • 1882–85 – MLA for St Leonards; advocates North Shore progress and a harbour bridge contribution (ADB).
  • 29 Apr 1885 – Dies on his 47th birthday; buried St Thomas’s (ADB).
  • Post-1885 – Dibbs purchase; sale to Shore School.
  • Mid-1930s – Mansion/tower encased / demolished into school fabric (At Home).
  • Live blog 2021-03 – Single historic image stub, misspelt title.

Architecture & interiors

Italianate mansion typical of mining-magnate display: central tower with Corinthian-suggestion pilasters, verandah cast iron, decorative masonry (At Home). Interiors sparsely described in consulted sources — contemporary papers called it fit for a nobleman (Singleton Argus 27 Oct 1875, cited At Home). Stained-glass self-portrait with the specimen is the signature interior anecdote (ADB). Prefer SLNSW exterior/panorama plates over inventing room schedules.

People & anecdotes

Bernhardt Otto Holtermann — German-born miner-made-good; Hill End partner of Beyers; MLA; immigrant-publicist via photography. Charles Bayliss (and earlier Beaufoy Merlin) — the cameras behind the Holtermann Collection. Thomas Dibbs — Graythwaite neighbour; intermediary owner. Shore School — long custodian of the site after the mansion’s erasure.

What stands today

The Towers does not stand as a readable mansion. The Shore School campus occupies the Lavender Bay ridge site; mid-1930s brick encasement destroyed the Italianate house and tower. Remember the place through the Holtermann Collection at the State Library of NSW and through surviving panorama plates — not through a house museum.

Sources & further reading

  • At Home in North Sydney (North Sydney Council) — ‘The Towers’: https://www.athomeinnorthsydney.com.au/the-towers.html
  • ADB — Holtermann, Bernhardt Otto (1838–1885): https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/holtermann-berhardt-otto-3787
  • State Library of NSW — Holtermann Collection
  • Live post (misspelt URL retained): https://historicsydneymansionsmanorshouses.blogspot.com/2021/03/holterman-mansion-lavendar-bay-nsw.html
  • Wikipedia — Bernhardt Holtermann

Related on this blog

  • Graythwaite / North Sydney ridge houses — search labels
  • Holtermann Collection / photography scrap posts if present
  • Other demolished Lavender Bay / Milsons Point mansions

Historic live gallery

Images retained from the live Blogger post:

“Mundarrah Towers” - Clovelly Beach - New South Wales

Mundarrah Towers – Burnie Street / Little Coogee (Clovelly) – NSW

Castellated marine villa · Core mid-19th century; towers added c.1874–76 · Demolished mid-1920s (sources 1923 / 1926) — Clovelly Hotel later on part of the estate

Before Clovelly had a tram, a hotel, or even its modern name, the western head of the bay was dominated by a castellated pile called Mundarrah Towers.

At a glance

  • Location: Land around Burnie Street, overlooking the western end of Clovelly Bay (then Little Coogee); Mundarrah Street remembers the house (Randwick Council)
  • Earlier names on the same ground: Rockbrook / Rock Brook (Dr Dickson / Dixon); Aberburnie (John Campbell) (Randwick ourstory / Bennett research)
  • Grand phase: Samuel Bennett (proprietor, Australian Town and Country Journal / Evening News world) bought August 1874; towers and renovations c.1874–76; family in residence from 1877 (Bennett research)
  • Style: Castellated / towered marine villa absorbing an earlier homestead (Randwick / Bennett)
  • Estate: c.20 acres at purchase (Bennett); subdivided from c.1908–1910 as Little Coogee Beach Estate etc.
  • Fate: Demolished mid-1920s — 1926 (Randwick Council / ourstory) or 1923 (Bennett site / some secondary); Clovelly Hotel from 1925 on part of the former estate (Randwick / Bennett)
  • Heritage today: Demolished — street name + photographs only

Site & setting

Gadigal / Bidjigal coastal Country — fishing and camping country later called Little Coogee, then Clovelly (name change associated with 1913 progress-association campaign; Wikipedia / Randwick). In 1834 William Charles Greville paid £40 for 20 acres on the beachfront; Greville Street remembers him (Randwick ourstory).

Through the nineteenth century the head of the bay was dominated by one grand estate. Mundarrah Towers sat on the slopes overlooking the western end of the bay around today’s Burnie Street. Neighbouring Gordon’s Bay held Cliffbrook (Thompson; later Commonwealth Bank governor; substantially demolished 1976) — another lost coastal mansion in the same Randwick story (Randwick Council).

Timeline

  • 1834 – W. C. Greville purchases 20 acres at Little Coogee cove for £40 (Randwick ourstory).
  • 1853 / 1860s – Dr Dickson / Dixon builds a mansion (Rockbrook / Rock Brook) with elaborate gardens; later first returning officer for Randwick municipal elections 1859 (Bennett: 1853; Randwick historic suburbs: “1860s”; ourstory: Dixon then sales chain).
  • 1860 / 1866 – Sold toward John Campbell; renamed Aberburnie.
  • 1872 – George Renwick purchase (Bennett); quickly on to Samuel Bennett.
  • Aug 1874 – Samuel and Eliza Bennett purchase ~20 acres with homestead, stables, coach-house and dairy as retirement marine villa (Bennett research).
  • 1874–76 – Renovations; towers added; estate expanded 1875–77; Bennetts move in 1877 (Bennett).
  • 1878 – Samuel dies while landscaping on the estate; Eliza mistress until 1886 (Bennett).
  • 1886–88 – Mundarrah Towers Trust; consolidation by Alfred Bennett 1888; Alfred forced to sell 1895 (Bennett).
  • 1908–1910 – Disposal / subdivision of Mundarrah Estate; Walter Lumley buys The Towers 1910; Little Coogee Beach Estate Section 1 sale 1910 (Bennett).
  • 1913 – Locality name Clovelly gains currency (Wikipedia / Randwick).
  • trong>Mid-1920s – Towers demolished (19231926 Randwick Council & ourstory).
  • 1925–present – Clovelly Hotel on part of the former estate ground (Randwick / Bennett).
  • Today – Mundarrah Street; hotel and suburban Clovelly; photographs in SLNSW / local collections.

Architecture & interiors

Period photographs show a multi-towered, castellated marine villa — stone or rendered walls, steep roofs, and the “towers” that gave the place its later name after Bennett’s 1870s works absorbed the earlier Dickson/Campbell house (Randwick: Bennett “absorbing Dixon’s original house”). No consulted source names an architect for the tower phase — leave blank rather than guess. Interiors are poorly documented in the public web sources used here; prefer captioned album views over invented room schedules.

People & anecdotes

Samuel Bennett — newspaper proprietor linked to The Australian Town and Country Journal and the Evening News circle; bought Little Coogee ground as a quiet retirement seat six miles from the CBD (Bennett research / Randwick). Eliza Bennett ran the house after Samuel’s 1878 death until 1886. Later Bennett-family tenure (Alfred; trust; forced sale) and early twentieth-century subdivision turned one marine villa into the street grid Clovelly knows.

Randwick Council’s suburban history still treats Mundarrah Towers and Cliffbrook as the “hidden heritage” of the northern coastal suburbs — grand houses erased for hotel, flats, and tram-era streets.

What stands today

Nothing of the mansion. Clovelly Hotel (from 1925), Mundarrah Street, Burnie Street suburban fabric, and the bay itself. Pair with Randwick’s Cliffbrook story and other Eastern Beaches demolitions on this blog. Respect private property; photograph from public streets and the bay foreshore only.

If you've had a cold one on the deck of the Clovelly Hotel, you've been drinking on the site of one of the eastern suburbs' great lost houses. Mundarrah Towers was a castellated sandstone mansion with battlemented towers and Gothic colonnades. It looked straight down Little Coogee Bay, which we now call Clovelly. It began in the 1850s as a doctor's farmhouse called Rockbrook. Newspaper proprietor Samuel Bennett, of the Evening News and the Australian Town and Country Journal, then turned it into a seaside castle in the 1870s. It housed the Bennett family for years, was carved up in the land boom that came with the trams, and was pulled down in the 1920s for the pub. Today the only reminders are a couple of street names and a lot of old paperwork.

Here's the whole story, as far as the sources take it. They don't go as far as I'd like. No architect's name has come down to us, and the house appears in only a handful of photographs and one 1878 woodcut. Where the sources disagree, I've said so.

Little Coogee about 1900, glass plate negative

Little Coogee, as Clovelly was known, around 1900. A glass plate from the Tyrrell Collection. Tyrrell Photographic Collection, Powerhouse Museum, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Before the Towers: Yarana and Little Coogee

This was Eora country long before any Europeans arrived. The Bennett family historians at Bennetts of the Evening News say the Aboriginal name for the bay has been recorded as "Yarana". They also say the diarists of the First Fleet didn't record which clan owned the land between the harbour and Botany Bay. It could have been the Bidjigal, the Gameygal or the Cadigal, or it may have been shared country. Some accounts put Governor Phillip's meeting with a crowd of 200 to 300 Aboriginal people on 10 July 1788 at this bay. The same writers point out that more recent research, based on Surgeon John White's journal, places that meeting at Little Bay instead.

The Europeans named the place Little Coogee, after the bigger crescent of beach to the south, past Gordons Bay. Randwick Council says hunting and fishing were what first drew settlers out here.

Gordons Bay panorama

Gordons Bay, looking south from Clovelly. Dr Dickson's neighbour here was Cliffbrook, which may have inspired the name Rockbrook. Tim Grubb, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Greville's 20 Acres, 1834

The block that became Mundarrah Towers was first sold in 1834. According to the Bennett family research, a man called William Morricy applied that February to buy the 20 acres around the bay, with an upset price of ten shillings an acre. When it went to Crown auction on 13 June 1834, Morricy lost out to William Charles Greville, a clerk in the Colonial Secretary's office. That gave Greville the whole beachfront. Greville Street is named after him.

Greville didn't bother naming the place, and he didn't build a proper house on it. According to the Bennett site, the land was farmed, and before 1853 there were only two dwellings in the whole area. One was a hut on "Mr Greville's farm" and the other was on James Holmes's five acres next door.

Dr Dickson's Rockbrook

The first real house went up under Dr John Dickson, a medical man with a practice in Elizabeth Street. The Bennett researchers say he paid £1,000 for the 20 acres in September 1853. He called the estate Rockbrook, after the creek running down through it into the head of the bay, and built on a ridge south of that creek with a long view out to sea.

From their description, it was a good solid house. It was two storeys of stone in the Gothic Revival style, with a central porch facing west onto a driveway. Downstairs a central hall led to the parlour, drawing room, library and kitchen. Upstairs were four attic bedrooms, and the main one had a dressing room. A verandah at the back looked over the bay and the ocean. Out the back were a big stable with a hayloft, a coach-house and a dairy, and the doctor spent a lot of money fencing and landscaping the grounds.

A racing daughter and a stack of debt

This is where it gets colourful. The Bennett site says Dickson's daughter Mary was a racehorse owner and trainer, and they suggest the levelled oval in front of the house may have been her training track. She was always short of money, and according to the same writers she turned to scams to get by, including selling horses she didn't own. One press report has her hiding a racehorse inside the house so it couldn't be repossessed.

By 1858 Dickson himself was in financial trouble. He tried transferring the property to his wife, and he tried subdividing and selling it. In the end his mortgagee used its power of sale in 1866, and the estate went to John Campbell of Campbell's Commercial Wharf for £926 17s 6d. Randwick Council's history also notes that Dickson (spelt "Dixon" there) was the first returning officer for the Randwick municipal elections in 1859.

Aberburnie: Campbell and Renwick

Campbell renamed the place Aberburnie, which the Bennett researchers translate from the Scots as "the mouth of the brook". He doesn't seem to have changed the house much. He did make a deal with Randwick Council to split the cost of rebuilding the "Government Road" from Arden Street to his front gate, and that road became Burnie Street. He lived there with his family until 1871. Then money troubles hit him too, and in October 1872 the Commercial Banking Company of Sydney sold the property to George Renwick of Redfern, a builder.

Renwick put it up for auction on 11 October 1873 and it seems not to have sold. In August 1874 he sold it privately to Samuel Bennett.

Front page of the Australian Town and Country Journal, 8 January 1870

The Australian Town and Country Journal, 8 January 1870. This was Samuel Bennett's paper, and it paid for the Towers. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Samuel Bennett Builds His Castle

Samuel Bennett was 59 and easing towards retirement. He owned the Evening News and the Australian Town and Country Journal, which Randwick Council calls "one of the most influential newspapers of the day". He and his wife Eliza were living in the city at Ashmore House in Kent Street, close to the paper, while their son Alfred was being groomed to take over. The Little Coogee farm, six miles out of town and quiet, was meant to be their retirement home.

Bennett didn't knock Rockbrook down. He wrapped it in something much grander. The Bennett researchers compared an 1888 Public Works plan with the 1866 subdivision plan and worked out what he added between 1874 and 1876. At the front and on the north side came terraces edged with stone balustrades. Then came the castellated towers, joined to the entrance porch by walkways with Gothic colonnades. Randwick Council calls the result the locally famous "castellated Mundarrah Towers", built around Dickson's original house. Later press reports apparently said Bennett spent as much on the outside of the house and the gardens as Dickson had spent building it.

The earliest known photograph, taken in 1879, shows the old gables and pitched roofs of Dickson's house and outbuildings still poking up behind the new castle front. The Illustrated Sydney News ran a woodcut of the nearly finished house, seen from the bay, on 17 September 1878. It's attributed to Arthur Collingridge, and the same issue carried an article and a poem called "Mundarrah".

Buying up the neighbours

Twenty acres wasn't enough for him. Between 1875 and 1877 he bought Lot 8 for £150, Lot 9 for £212 3s and Lot 6 for £400, which added more than 16 acres along both sides of the road out to Arden Street. The building work took so long that he and Eliza didn't move in until 1877, and the 1877 Sands Directory lists them at both Kent Street and Little Coogee.

Clovelly Beach looking north

Clovelly Beach and the narrow bay in 2023. The Towers stood on the slope above the western end, at the head of the bay. DXR, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why "Mundarrah"?

Nobody really knows, and the best story might be a joke. The name appears from the mid-1870s, after the Bennetts arrived. The Bennett site quotes an article from the Town and Country Journal of September 1878, which was Bennett's own paper. It tells of "a lady" who wanted an Aboriginal name for her house and bribed an Aboriginal man with tea and sugar to tell her what the place was called. She heard either "Munyarra" or "Mundarrah" and chose the second. The family researchers say they couldn't confirm the word in the Sydney language. They point out that by then the man could have come from almost anywhere in New South Wales. They also suggest that for a story like that to run in the family's own paper, the Bennetts must have been happy to laugh at themselves.

A Tragedy in the Garden

Samuel Bennett barely got to enjoy the place. In June 1878 he hurt his left forefinger helping the stonemasons with their work, and he died of tetanus. He was 63 and otherwise in robust health, and he'd lived in his castle for just over a year.

Eliza, Mistress of Mundarrah Towers

Eliza inherited the estate and stayed on until she died. Her daughter Rose and Rose's husband John Henniker Heaton lived there with her until they left for England in 1883. One of the few photographs of the Towers shows a family group at the christening of two of Samuel and Eliza's grandchildren. Going by the size of the Norfolk Island pines, the family historians date it to about 1880.

Mrs Bennett's picnic, Good Friday 1884

The other great photograph comes from a staff party. On Good Friday, 11 April 1884, Eliza hosted the employees of the Evening News and the Town and Country Journal at the Towers. The Town and Country Journal reported on it on 19 April. In the group photo Eliza sits in the middle with Alfred and his wife Emily. Down the front, sitting on the grass, is a man you can't mistake: Sir Henry Parkes. He had founded the Empire, the paper Samuel Bennett had started out on, and he stayed close to the family. Alfred's son Len later recalled being told that Sir Henry had bounced him on his knee as a baby.

Sir Henry Parkes in the 1890s

Sir Henry Parkes in the 1890s. He was a guest at Eliza Bennett's staff picnic at the Towers in 1884. John Hubert Newman, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In 1885 Eliza transferred a building block on the south-west corner to Dr George Heape Stanley, the first minister of Sydney's Unitarian Church and an old family friend. Nobody knows whether he paid for it. The Bennett researchers think it was most likely a gift, since Eliza's estate was later valued at over £94,000.

Eliza died at Mundarrah Towers on 3 December 1886. Rose had come back from England to be with her. The house and land were valued for probate at £9,500, and the valuation flagged the problem that would dog the estate for decades. Much of it was "rendered unsaleable and inaccessible by an immense water course traversing it in two directions, being sand, the wash away is considerable after storms."

John Henniker Heaton MP

John Henniker Heaton, MP for Canterbury and Samuel and Eliza Bennett's son-in-law, pictured in 1907. Arena Magazine, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Heatons, the Trust and a Baronet "of Mundarrah Towers"

Eliza's will left the estate in trust for Rose for as long as she lived in the homestead. After Rose, it was to go to her eldest son John for his lifetime. Neither of them ever came back to live there, so the executors sold up and kept the money in trust as the "Mundarrah Towers Fund". The trust wasn't finally wound up until 1963, when that son, by then Sir John Henniker-Heaton, Baronet, died.

Rose's husband was quite a figure himself. Wikipedia describes John Henniker Heaton (1848–1914) as a Conservative MP and postal reformer who had been a journalist in Australia. The Bennett site says he won the seat of Canterbury in the House of Commons. When he was made a baronet, the title took its territorial name from a Clovelly creek bank: there's a 1912 coat of arms on Wikimedia Commons for the "Henniker-Heaton baronets of Mundarrah Towers".

Vanity Fair caricature of John Henniker Heaton

"International Penny Postage": Henniker Heaton in Vanity Fair, 17 September 1887. Leslie Ward (Spy), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Coat of arms of the Henniker-Heaton baronets of Mundarrah Towers

The arms of the Henniker-Heaton baronets "of Mundarrah Towers" (1912). A Clovelly house name ended up in an English baronetcy. Charles Matthews, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Alfred Bennett, Drains and the 1890s Crash

When the property was auctioned on 23 March 1888, Eliza's son Alfred bought the original 20 acres plus Lots 6, 8 and 9 for £15,100, all on mortgage. In August he paid his brother Christopher £4,500 for Lots 4 and 7. On 4 September 1889 he brought the whole 46 acres under Torrens title. He spent hundreds of pounds trying to fix the drainage so the land could be subdivided. He even thought about demolishing the Towers, and in March 1892 he tried, without success, to sell allotments. Then the 1890s depression caught him overextended, and by 1895 he had to hand his interest over to his siblings Frank, Christopher and Rose.

Clovelly Beach at high tide

Clovelly Beach at high tide. In the Bennetts' day a creek ran down through the estate into the head of this bay. Snowdrop Fairy, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Trams, Subdivision and a North Sydney Butcher

The family waited for the economy to recover before selling. Between 1908 and 1910 the land went on the market as the Little Coogee Beach Estate and the Mundarrah Estate. Rose was the last Bennett to hold land there, and she sold her final interest in 1909. Randwick Council says Clovelly's subdivision "began in earnest in 1909". It adds that the progress association lobbied for a tram, arguing that 717 houses had been built within metres of the proposed route.

The 63 lots of the Little Coogee Beach Estate, Section 1, were auctioned on 19 March 1910. The papers reported every lot sold, for a total of £5,808 17s, but the Bennett researchers found that only 18 of those sales were ever completed. The lot with the Towers on it went to Walter Lumley, a North Sydney butcher, who also bought the lot next door.

The tram changed everything. In 1913 the government resumed most of the northern parts of the lots along the creek for the Clovelly tram loop along Donnellan Circuit. Lumley ended up with just under 1¼ acres, and the Towers sat alone on an "island" cut off by the resumptions. The only other building there was a small four-bedroom cottage he put up below it in 1914.

Old photograph of Clovelly Beach

An undated view of Clovelly Beach from the State Archives of NSW. State Archives and Records NSW, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Little Coogee Becomes Clovelly

With the tram coming, the locals wanted a name that wouldn't be confused with Coogee. Randwick Council says the Little Coogee Progress Association ran a competition in 1914. The winner was "Clovelly", after the fishing village in Devon, suggested by the association's president, Mr F. H. Howe. It beat "Eastbourne", which lives on as Eastbourne Avenue. Wikipedia, citing The Book of Sydney Suburbs, dates the change to 1913. It also says Howe took the name from a local estate called Clovelly owned by Sir John Robertson, which had itself been named after the Devon village.

Clovelly village in Devon, England

The original Clovelly, the fishing village on the north Devon coast that gave Little Coogee its new name. nick macneill, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Main Street, Clovelly, Devon

Main Street in Clovelly, Devon, photographed in 1969. Derek Voller, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Demolition and the Clovelly Hotel

According to the Bennett researchers, the Lumleys lived at the Towers until 1923, when it was demolished to make way for a hotel. Randwick Council and Wikipedia both give the demolition as 1926 (see below). Walter Lumley got a publican's licence in June 1925 for "a premises proposed to be erected in Burnie-street, Clovelly", and tenders went out a month later. The hotel was finished by March 1926. William Westphal took the lease and the licence in June 1926 but ran into money trouble and was gone by 1930. In 1955 Lumley handed the property to his five sons in equal shares, and in 1967 they sold it to Imelda Small, who was then the licensee. The family site notes that the leasehold last changed hands in 2018, sold by the Solotel Group.

The Clovelly Hotel

The Clovelly Hotel in Burnie Street, built in 1925–26 on the Towers site. Kgbo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What's There Today

Nothing of the house survives that I could find. The Clovelly Hotel, "the Cloey", stands on the site in Burnie Street, which began life as Dickson's and Campbell's driveway road. Randwick Council says the estate covered the land around Burnie Street overlooking the western end of Clovelly Bay, and that Mundarrah Street "honours this once grand part of Clovelly's heritage". Greville Street remembers the first buyer. With the house long gone, I couldn't find a heritage listing for it either. Council describes it, along with Cliffbrook at Gordons Bay, as part of the "hidden heritage" of the northern coastal suburbs.

Another view of the Clovelly Hotel

The "Cloey" today. Nothing of the Towers is left above ground. Kgbo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A house in Clovelly

A Clovelly house from the suburban boom that followed the break-up of the estate. Kgbo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Bay Around It

A few other bits of Clovelly history are worth knowing, because the Towers looked out on all of them. Randwick Council says Shark Point, at the mouth of the bay, was a defence battery from 1879, part of the coastal forts built against fears of a Russian attack. During the Depression of 1929–33, relief works built the concrete platforms along the bay. The plan was to link them with a causeway across the mouth of the bay that cars could use, but a big storm in 1938 wrecked it and the project was abandoned. Its remains still show at low tide. The surf club dates from the first years of the twentieth century. On 5 December 1927 more than 30 lifesavers went out in the "Rescue off Schnapper Rocks" and saved four of five boys caught by the tide. The fifth, 19-year-old Thomas Wooldridge, drowned. Council also says that for a while the area was known as "Poverty Point", which is hard to believe given today's house prices.

Shark Point, Clovelly

Shark Point at the mouth of Clovelly Bay. According to Randwick Council, a defence battery stood here from 1879. Maurice van Creij, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Clovelly Beach and its concrete platforms

The concrete platforms along the bay date from Depression-era relief works. J Bar, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Clovelly Surf Life Saving Club

Clovelly Surf Life Saving Club, one of the oldest in the world. Kgbo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Waverley Cemetery on the cliffs

Waverley Cemetery runs along the cliffs on the northern side of the bay. Maurice van Creij, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Before 1788: Eora country. The bay is recorded as "Yarana".

13 June 1834: William Charles Greville buys the 20 acres around Little Coogee Bay at Crown auction.

September 1853: Dr John Dickson buys the land for £1,000 and builds Rockbrook, a two-storey Gothic Revival stone house.

1859: Dickson is returning officer at Randwick's first municipal election.

1866: The mortgagee sells to John Campbell, who renames the house Aberburnie (Council gives 1860).

October 1872: The bank sells to George Renwick, builder, of Redfern.

August 1874: Samuel Bennett buys the estate.

1874–76: Towers, terraces and Gothic colonnades are added. The name Mundarrah appears.

1875–77: Bennett buys Lots 8, 9 and 6.

1877: Samuel and Eliza move in.

17 September 1878: The Illustrated Sydney News publishes the Collingridge woodcut.

June 1878: Samuel dies of tetanus after hurting his finger on the stonework.

1879: The earliest known photograph is taken. Council dates the Shark Point defences from this year.

11 April 1884: Eliza's Good Friday staff picnic, with Sir Henry Parkes among the guests.

3 December 1886: Eliza dies at the Towers. The estate goes into trust for Rose Heaton.

23 March 1888: Alfred Bennett buys the estate at auction, and consolidates 46 acres by 1889.

1895: Depression. Alfred hands his interest to Frank, Christopher and Rose.

1908–10: The estate is subdivided and sold.

19 March 1910: The Little Coogee Beach Estate auction. Walter Lumley buys the Towers lot.

1913: The tram reaches Clovelly, and the resumptions leave the Towers on an "island".

1913 or 1914: Little Coogee is renamed Clovelly.

1923 or 1926: Mundarrah Towers is demolished.

1925–26: The Clovelly Hotel is licensed and built on the site.

1963: Sir John Henniker-Heaton dies and the Mundarrah Towers trust is finally distributed.

1967: The Lumley sons sell the hotel to licensee Imelda Small.

Where the Sources Disagree

The doctor's name. Randwick Council's suburb page, Wikipedia and the Bennett family site say "Dickson". Council's Our Story Clovelly page says "Dr John Dixon".

What Greville paid. Council and Wikipedia say £40. The Bennett site gives £44, or £2 4s an acre.

Who built it and when. Council and Wikipedia say Mundarrah Towers "was built for Dr Dickson in the 1860s". The Bennett site has Dickson buying in 1853 and building Rockbrook in the 1850s, and has the towers added by Samuel Bennett in 1874–76. My own A–Z of homes list gives 1863.

The ownership chain. Council's Our Story page has Dickson selling to Campbell in 1860 and Campbell selling to Renwick two years later. The Bennett site, working from the land titles, has a mortgagee sale to Campbell in 1866, a bank sale to Renwick in October 1872, and the sale to Bennett in August 1874.

Demolition. Randwick Council (both pages) and the Clovelly News say 1926. The Bennett site says 1923, and so does my A–Z of homes list. The hotel was built in 1925–26, so the 1926 date may really be the hotel's opening year.

The renaming of Clovelly. Council says the competition was held in 1914. Wikipedia says the name changed in 1913, and it adds that Howe took the name from Sir John Robertson's Clovelly estate.

The surf club. Council dates it to 1907, Wikipedia to 1906.

Governor Phillip's 1788 meeting. Some accounts place it at Little Coogee, but more recent research cited on the Bennett site puts it at Little Bay.

My Earlier Posts

The A – Z Of Homes In Sydney – As I Find Them. Mundarrah Towers is listed under M.

Clovelly – Watsons Bay – New South Wales

Sydney Trams – From Horse Trams to Light Rail

Bennetts of the Evening News, "Mundarrah Towers, Little Coogee (Clovelly)" and its timeline pages: overview, The Original Occupants, Crown Land Grant, Dr Dickson builds Rockbrook, John Campbell / Aberburnie, George Renwick, Samuel Bennett purchases, The towers are added, Expanding the estate, Samuel and Eliza move in, Why Mundarrah Towers?, Samuel dies, Eliza, Mistress of Mundarrah Towers, Eliza's death, The Mundarrah Towers Trust, Alfred Bennett, Alfred forced to sell, Disposal of the estate, 1910 sale, Walter Lumley, Demolition, The Clovelly Hotel.

Randwick City Council, Our Story, "Clovelly 2031".

Wikipedia, "Clovelly, New South Wales", citing Frances Pollon (comp.), The Book of Sydney Suburbs, Angus & Robertson, 1990, p. 64.

Wikipedia, "John Henniker Heaton".

Wikimedia Commons, for the images credited under each picture.

Sources & further reading

  • Randwick City Council — Historic suburbs (Clovelly / Mundarrah Towers): https://www.randwick.nsw.gov.au/about-us/history/historic-places/historic-suburbs
  • Randwick ourstory — “Clovelly 2031”: https://ourstory.randwick.nsw.gov.au/nodes/view/2178
  • Bennetts of the Evening News — Mundarrah Towers timeline: https://bennettsoftheeveningnews.com/residences/mundarrah-towers/mundarrah-towers-little-coogee-clovelly/
  • Wikipedia — Clovelly, New South Wales (council-derived summary; check citations)
  • SLNSW / Trove — search Mundarrah Towers, Little Coogee, Clovelly Hotel

Related on this blog

Gallery

“Kinneil” - Potts Point - NSW

 



“Kinneil” - Potts Point NSW






Originally Barnclueth - 






_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________









Sydney Morning Herald - Tuesday 30 November 1937, page 13



Transcription (Sydney Morning Herald, Tuesday 30 November 1937, pages 13 and 18, Parts 1–6)

GHOSTS IN CRINOLINES
WHEN KING'S CROSS WAS DOTTED WITH STATELY HOMES.
People Then Slept in Four-Posters.

A GREAT effort is required to imagine that King's Cross—the present throbbing centre of Sydney's night life—was once sparsely dotted with stately homes, where demure ladies drove leisurely through private avenues of trees in their carriages.

Those were the days when land was owned by the acre. To-day, despite stout resistance to the demolishers' picks, century-old homes are being knocked down so that the task of converting King's Cross into a swarming, human ant-hill may proceed unimpeded.

ROSLYN HALL and Orwell House are already man-made ruins, and a similar fate awaits Kellett House, Springfield, and Larbert Lodge. But before modern mammoth structures completely annihilate even the memory of their long lives, these last survivors of a bygone age merit at least a brief obituary.

Once the most imposing of them all, Roslyn Hall is now a lamentable spectacle. Its floors have been ripped out and the back and front pulled down.

Stripped of its former majesty, it now confronts, over wrought-iron gates, a huge, nearly completed, ultra-modern seven-storey block of flats across the road.

Destruction and construction have kept pace, so that the final brick of the new edifice, which dwarfs everything else nearby, will be laid at almost the same moment as the last stone from the ancient dwelling is carted away.

Gilded dados and wallpapers of a chaste design are exposed to curiosity, while a few surviving trees and shrubs huddle together in the northern end of the grounds, sighing mournfully for other days.

Governor Darling's Grant.

ROSLYN HALL, or what is left of it, is a relic of the spacious times of King's Cross and Elizabeth Bay when Governor Darling made grants with a lavish hand. That to Thomas Barker, on November 28, 1833, was an area of five acres one rood, and on it he built Roslyn Hall.

An iron lattice gate opened on to Darlinghurst Road, opposite Springfield House. It was the entrance to land which sloped down to the south-east, taking in the present Roslyn Street and Roslyn Gardens.

A similar gate, on the site now occupied by St. Canice's Church, led out to Bayswater Road. On the north, Barncleuth (now Kinneil) and Elizabeth Bay Road marked the boundary of the domain.

Beautiful Spiral Staircase.

A LARGE, well-built, two-storey stone mansion, Roslyn Hall was flanked on two sides by high verandahs supported by massive stone columns. Among the amenities not usual in those days were a beautiful spiral staircase leading to the upper storey, and sunken baths level with the floors in most of the bedrooms.

Houses in the district were few and far apart, and because of its imposing architectural and elevated position, Roslyn Hall had a grandeur equalled only by that of its neighbour, Elizabeth Bay House.

Fashionable Garden Parties.

FOR many years Roslyn Hall was one of the gayest houses in Sydney. Its high halls echoed to the laughter of dancing throngs, and birds in the widespread grounds became accustomed to the light-hearted chatter at fashionable garden parties.

After the original owner, Thomas Barker, the house saw a succession of occupants, including Mrs. Wm. Lawson and her two daughters, a Mr. Chauvel, and the Hon. Wm. Macleay.

For the last quarter of a century, however, Echo had little to answer except the footsteps of a lonely woman, Mrs. Parry Long, who died there a few years ago after her daughter had predeceased her.

Now the grey old stone is being carted away to make room for the foundations of a resplendent block of flats.

Darlinghurst's Origin.

SOLD last month, Kellett House, standing in the street which bears its name, is another historic home in the same locality.

It was built on part of the grant, dated October 19, 1831, to Captain S. A. Perry, Deputy Surveyor-General. He resided there until 1836.

In that year, Richard ("China") Jones sold his house at the corner of Pitt and Hunter Streets for £9000, and moved into Perry's place, which was then called "Bona Vista."

In 1817 Jones had established himself in business as an importer of merchandise from China and India—especially of Bengal rum. His office was also the first in Australia to undertake marine insurance.

Because of her friendship with Lady Darling, Mrs. Jones renamed the house "Darlinghurst," but her husband's financial position was severely shaken by the trade depression of 1843, and the home passed into the possession of Sir Stuart Alexander Donaldson, the first Premier under responsible government, who changed the name to Kellett House.

He lived there for some years, and subsequently the property was acquired by W. F. Buchanan. He pulled down part of the house and built the terrace (still there) which used to be known as Bayswater Terrace.

Hidden from Macleay Street by a two-storey terrace, Orwell House, at various times the home of distinguished men, is being demolished to provide the site for a new theatre.

It originally stood on 11 acres 37 perches, granted on October 19, 1831, to Mr. Justice John Stephens, first Pusine [sic] Judge of the colony after the charter of justice. Among subsequent occupants were James Raymond (then Postmaster-General), Colonel H. C. Wilson, Mr. Justice Milford, and in 1848 Sir W. Manning.

Up to a few days ago the original house was still standing, but hemmed in by buildings in Darlinghurst Road and Hughes Street, to both of which the grounds extended, even in comparatively recent times.

(Continued on page 18.)

[Picture captions:]
(Top.) Only the lines of its architecture indicate Kinneil's old age.
(Above.) Larbert, seen across its spacious garden, which will soon be covered with flat buildings like the one in the distance.
(Left.) Ruins of Roslyn Hall and the towering modern edifice opposite.
Orwell House is falling rapidly under the demolishers' picks.
Larbert provides an 1837 background for two 1937 tennis girls (MISSES MONA ZEPPEL and LOIS GREEN).

[Page 18:]
Ghosts in Crinoline.
OLD STABLES ON MACLEAY STREET.

(Continued from page 13.)

ONLY a gunshot away, and also doomed to destruction, is Larbert Lodge, a quaint house which might have been modelled on Hawthorne's "House of the Seven Gables."

Old stables are almost flush with Macleay Street, and the remains of its grounds extend to Greenknowe Flats. It is enclosed by high walls designed to shield its privacy, but, ironically enough, surrounding flats are so high that probably no dwelling in Sydney is so exposed to the gaze of strangers.

Larbert Lodge was built by the Hon. Campbell Drummond Riddell (Colonial Treasurer from 1831 to 1854, and Acting Colonial Secretary in 1855 and 1856) on one of the first blocks of the Macleay grant made available. It was subsequently acquired by Captain Lamb, who was followed by a succession of private owners.

This property, which has a frontage of 190ft to Macleay Street and 234ft to Greenknowe Avenue, was recently sold and subdivided into eight allotments on which flats will be erected.

Springfield House, another sacrifice to progress, was built on a grant dated October 19, 1831, by Alexander Baxter, second Attorney-General under the charter.

All Were Neighbours.

ALL the homes mentioned were neighbouring properties, but during the course of the years block after block of their land was disposed of and built on to house a rapidly growing population.

Their few remaining contemporaries in the immediate locality are easily enumerated.

On the original Macleay grant, David Jones built Cheverells and Kinneil (formerly Barncleuth). He sold Cheverells to Captain Deloitte, who included it in his marriage settlement.

After several renovations, both houses are in good condition, and are used as guest houses.

It may seem strange that residences like these were built so close to the city, but the district was by no means easily accessible. Vehicular traffic had to take a round-about route along Hyde Park up to the part of Old South Head Road, now called Oxford Street, to the gaol, and from there across to Darlinghurst Hill.

A trip to the city was therefore long enough to be a minor event in a woman's week, and sufficiently slow for prolonged meditation or conversation as the carriage described almost a semi-circle.

Only a track for pedestrians existed on the site of William Street until 1845, when Sir Thomas Mitchell, Surveyor-General, surveyed the extension which halved the distance to the city.

—Joseph Reidle.



Sydney Morning Herald - Tuesday 30 November 1937, page 18







“Osterley” - Fitzroy Gardens - Potts Point

Osterley – 62 Macleay Street – Potts Point – NSW

Built mid-19th century (see date note) · Demolished 1927 · Site became the first stage of Fitzroy Gardens (landscaped 1939)

Osterley was the Macleay Street house whose clearance opened the first slice of today’s Fitzroy Gardens. Demolished in 1927, interim-used for miniature golf and tennis, it was resumed and landscaped in 1939 — originally to be named for Alderman Ernest Tresidder before politics delivered the Fitzroy name. The Paradise Theatre planned for this ground was never built.

At a glance

  • Address: 62 Macleay Street, Potts Point (City of Sydney). ADB places the Broadhurst matrimonial house at 72 Macleay Street
  • Built: City of Sydney park history — 1870s. City heritage assessment narrative — mid-1850s for barrister Edward Broadhurst
  • Early household: Edward Broadhurst (1810–1883), barrister (“father of the Bar”); wife Harriet Lucy, née Greenhill; marriage 7 May 1853; father-in-law Stephen Greenhill settled a Macleay Street house on them (ADB)
  • Later: Daughter Frances Harriet inherits (1884 in heritage assessment); later private occupants include Sir Adrian Knox immediately before 1927 demolition (assessment caption)
  • 1927: Minerva Centre Limited purchase reported at £25,000 in heritage assessment; house demolished 1927
  • Interim uses: Tom Thumb Miniature Golf (early 1930s); Grimes’ Garage / commercial tennis with kiosk (late 1930s)
  • Fate: Landscaped into Fitzroy Gardens 1939 (first stage); name shifted from Tresidder to Fitzroy (ward / Governor FitzRoy)

Site & setting

Part of Alexander Macleay’s 1841 Elizabeth Bay Estate subdivision — the same high Macleay Street band that held Maramanah and Tenilba. Osterley’s demolition created the first public open-space bite; Maramanah (1943 purchase, 1954 demolition) and Tenilba enlarged it.

Timeline

  • 1853 – Edward Broadhurst marries Harriet Lucy Greenhill; ADB: Stephen Greenhill settles a house at 72 Macleay Street on them as matrimonial home (England visit 1859 excepted).
  • mid-1850s / 1870s – Osterley fabric date: follow either the heritage-assessment mid-1850s Broadhurst association or the CoS “built in the 1870s” park page — both published.
  • 1883 – Broadhurst dies (7 April); bronchial retirement from practice (ADB).
  • 1884 – Heritage assessment: Frances Harriet inherits and lives on.
  • March 1927 – Photographed vacant / immediately prior to demolition; Sir Adrian Knox recently vacated (CoS Archives image 1544 via heritage assessment).
  • 1927 – Demolished after Minerva Centre Limited purchase (£25,000 in assessment). Paradise Theatre for Macleay Street never realised; Minerva Theatre proceeds on Orwell Street (1939).
  • early 1930s – Tom Thumb Miniature Golf Course on the cleared site.
  • late 1930s – Grimes Garage and commercial tennis / kiosk.
  • 1939 – Resumed and landscaped as the first stage of what becomes Fitzroy Gardens (Tresidder name dropped).
  • 1943–54 – Park enlarged via Maramanah / Tenilba (see Maramanah).
  • Today – Fitzroy Gardens plaza and fountain precinct.

Architecture & interiors

Rate valuations cited in the heritage assessment describe neighbouring Greenhill/Broadhurst-band Macleay Street houses of the 1860s–70s as brick, three floors, about eight rooms — useful context, not a measured description of Osterley’s final form.

People & anecdotes

Edward Broadhurst (ADB) – Cambridge rebel who forfeited his degree rather than make a religious declaration; colonial barrister of large practice; duel controversy with Robert Lowe (1844–45); Legislative Council; never a judge despite being talked of as “father of the Bar”. Osterley/Macleay Street was the domestic frame for that career.

Sir Adrian Knox — High Court Chief Justice; keen gardener; last private name attached to the house in the 1927 photo caption tradition.

David N. Martin / Minerva Centre — bought for a theatre dream (Paradise) that became a park instead — one of the Cross’s better near-misses.

What stands today

Osterley is gone. Its ground is the original cell of Fitzroy Gardens at 60–64 Macleay Street. Stand by the El Alamein Fountain and read the park as demolished houses.

Sources & further reading

  • City of Sydney History of Fitzroy Gardens: https://www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au/histories-local-parks-playgrounds/history-fitzroy-gardens
  • City of Sydney Council — Fitzroy Gardens / Macleay Street heritage assessment (2010 agenda attachment PDF; Osterley section)
  • ADB — Edward Broadhurst: https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/broadhurst-edward-3057
  • Dictionary of Sydney — Minerva Theatre / Metro Kings Cross (Paradise never built)




















Related on this blog

Historic live gallery

Images retained from the live Blogger post:

Transcription:

Osterley

“Maramanah” - Cnr Darlinghurst Road And Elizabeth Bay Road - Potts a Point

Transcription:

“Maramanah” Darlinghurst

Built 1882   Demolished 1954

FOR UNITS

[Note: City of Sydney says Maramanah was built in the 1860s; the council’s 2010 heritage assessment traces it to the early 1840s, with E. J. Sparke adding the tower, south wing and verandah after buying it in 1885. It was bought by the council in 1943 and demolished in 1954; its site became part of Fitzroy Gardens.]


 






“Maramanah” - Cnr Darlinghurst Road, Macleay Street & Elizabeth Bay Road - Potts Point NSW









At a glance

  • Address: 64 Macleay Street, Potts Point (Kings Cross), at Darlinghurst Road and Elizabeth Bay Road
  • Built: 1860s (City of Sydney); the heritage assessment gives early-1840s origins, enlarged by Edward Joseph Sparke from 1885
  • People: long the home of the Hollander family, remembered in Robin Eakin’s 1965 memoir Aunts up the Cross
  • Fate: bought by the City of Sydney in 1943; demolished 1954; site became part of Fitzroy Gardens (El Alamein Fountain 1961)

Sources

Thursday, March 4, 2021

Former St Peters Rectory – 188 Forbes Street – Darlinghurst – NSW

Former St Peters Rectory – 188 Forbes Street – Darlinghurst – NSW

Built c.1872–1873 · Architect not attributed here · Standing (RNE-listed former rectory)

On the triangle lot where Forbes Street meets Clapton Place — polychrome brick, steep patterned slate, cast-iron balcony, metal digits 188 on the sawtooth brick band — stands the house the Register of the National Estate recorded as St Peters Rectory (former). It was raised for the Anglican parish of St Peter’s (church by O. H. Lewis, 1866–67; hall by Benjamin Backhouse, 1873) and later returned to private residential use.

At a glance

  • Address / site: 188 Forbes Street, corner Clapton Place, Darlinghurst NSW 2010 (RNE location note; live-post street number confirmed on facade)
  • Built: c.1872–1873 (Wikipedia Darlinghurst heritage list / recent agent tradition 1872–73; City of Sydney Archives bond for awnings at 188 Forbes Street dated in the 1871 series)
  • Architect: not attributed for the rectory in sources used here (O. H. Lewis and Benjamin Backhouse designed the church and hall)
  • Style: freestanding multi-storey Victorian Gothic villa; polychromatic patterned brickwork; steep gabled / patterned slate roof; elaborate patterned brick chimneys; delicate cast-iron cantilevered balcony; attic level; garage inserted at southern end 1947 (RNE)
  • Original use: rectory for St Peter’s Church of England, Darlinghurst (parish church 1866–67 on Bourke / St Peters Street; hall 1873 on Forbes Street)
  • Estate context: Edward Deas Thomson / Barham grant country; St Peter’s precinct assembled from mid-century lots; church purchased further Forbes Street terraces in 1924 for forecourt (separate from this rectory lot)
  • Heritage status: Register of the National Estate place 1985 (registered 21 Mar 1978) as St Peters Rectory (former); noted on Wikipedia Darlinghurst heritage list; standing private house. The Sydney LEP item I300 “Former St Peter’s Church of England Group” is addressed at 159–163 Bourke / Forbes Street (church, hall, store)
  • Fate: standing; sold as renovated private residence (Aileen Sage Architects upgrade cited in 2025 marketing)

Site & setting

Forbes Street here is the lower Darlinghurst ridge edge toward the old St Peter’s parish — Barham and SCEGGS upslope, Clapton Place / Farrell Avenue toward the Rosebank and Rose Hall flat precinct, Bourke Street carrying the sandstone church that is now SCEGGS Great Hall. The rectory’s triangle lot and Clapton Place corner give it a freestanding silhouette rare among the terrace walls.

Live-post photographs (nine images) are mostly close fabric: Tudor-rose sandstone stops, cream-and-red arched window surrounds, sawtooth brick channel, balcony soffit, and the metal 188 — enough to lock the address to the polychrome Gothic villa the RNE described.

Timeline

  • Jan 1835 – Edward Deas Thomson grant recorded; Barham built early 1840s (still inside SCEGGS); mid-century subdivision creates the Forbes / St Peters Street lots (Heritage NSW St Peter’s group history).
  • 1866–67 – St Peter’s Church built (O. H. Lewis); vestry additions later (Wikipedia / SHR church precinct).
  • 1869–1870 – Church buys adjoining Forbes Street lots; some already house-occupied (group history).
  • 1871 series – City of Sydney Archives: bond for awnings at 188 Forbes Street (early address evidence).
  • c.1872–1873 – Rectory raised in Victorian Gothic polychrome brick (RNE description; build years from secondary heritage list / agent tradition). Church hall by Benjamin Backhouse, 1873, on Forbes Street (separate building).
  • 1924 – Church purchases five Forbes Street terraces and demolishes them for entry/forecourt to the church (Wikipedia) — precinct change, not demolition of 188.
  • 1947 – Garage incorporated at southern end (RNE).
  • 21 Mar 1978 – Register of the National Estate registration as St Peters Rectory (former), place ID 1985.
  • 1993 – St Peter’s Church closed and sold to SCEGGS (Great Hall / Playhouse) — rectory’s later private life is separate from the school’s church conversion.
  • 2020s – House marketed and sold as renovated freestanding residence; street number and polychrome fabric unchanged.

Architecture & interiors

The RNE sheet is the architectural spine: three-storey brick residence with attic; patterned walls and patterned slate roof; facade enlivened by a delicate cast-iron cantilevered balcony at first-floor level; very steep gable roof with elaborate patterned brick chimneys; 1947 garage at the southern end. Significance text calls it a fascinating example of polychromatic patterned brickwork in a quaint Victorian villa, Gothic style suited to rectory use, contributing to the lower Forbes Street / Clapton Place streetscape.

Live images match that reading — cream/red voussoirs, floral sandstone label stops, sawtooth recessed brick, balcony timber soffit.

People & anecdotes

This house’s identity is parochial before personal: built as the dwelling for St Peter’s clergy while the sandstone church and Forbes Street hall served the congregation. Parish associations recorded for the church precinct (Charles Kemp, Henry Connell, Lebbeus Hordern, Patrick White among later church-linked names) belong to the worship story, not proven rectory residents.

Edward Deas Thomson’s Barham grant is the deeper land layer; SCEGGS’s later ownership of the church/hall is a neighbour story. The rectory’s twentieth-century private chapters (including the 1947 garage and recent architectural upgrade) explain why the polychrome villa still faces Forbes Street when so much parish housing was cleared for the 1924 forecourt.

What stands today

The former rectory stands at 188 Forbes Street as a private house. Walk the Clapton Place corner for the gables and balcony; continue to SCEGGS Great Hall (former St Peter’s Church) and Playhouse (former hall) for the parish set; glance to Barham inside the school grounds and to Horizon for Rose Hall’s vacant sky.

  • Map pin: 188 Forbes Street, Darlinghurst (cnr Clapton Place).

Sources & further reading

  • Australian Heritage Database — St Peters Rectory (former), 188 Forbes St, Darlinghurst (RNE place 1985): https://environment.gov.au/cgi-bin/ahdb/search.pl?mode=place_detail;place_id=1985
  • Heritage NSW — Former St Peter’s Church of England Group (LEP I300 / database 2420326) — precinct context only: https://apps.environment.nsw.gov.au/dpcheritageapp/ViewHeritageItemDetails.aspx?ID=2420326
  • Wikipedia — St Peter’s Church, Darlinghurst (church/hall architects and 1924 forecourt)
  • Wikipedia — Darlinghurst (heritage list entry for 188 Forbes Street: St Peters Rectory (former))
  • City of Sydney Archives — bond for awnings at 188 Forbes Street (1871 series record)

Related on this blog

Historic live gallery

Images retained from the live Blogger post:

Transcription:

188

Transcription:

A.D.
1872

[Note: date carved on the gable bracket; matches the c.1872–73 build date in the post.]